Why Kindle flunked out
July 15, 2010 by Geneva ReidPosted in: In this week's e-newsletter, Latest News & Views, Tech News
Amazon’s Kindle went to college last fall — and it seems to have flunked out.
The e-reader was given to students at seven universities throughout the country. But it didn’t take long for students to voice their complaints:
“It just didn’t have the features or the sort of user friendliness to make it practical, let alone helpful,” Joe Chard, a University of Virginia business student, told BusinessWeek.com
The problems with the e-reader?
- It’s difficult and slow to navigate
- The file management system is inadequate
- There’s no easy way for students to underline or highlight text (as they would with a yellow marking pen)
- It’s tough to take notes on Kindle’s keyboard, and
- When texts are being discussed in class, it’s hard for Kindle readers to find the same sections.
According to BusinessWeek.com, more than half the students at some colleges said they would not recommend Kindle to their friends.
On the plus side, students spent less on the e-reader than they would have spent on textbooks — racking up savings of 75%.
Amazon is currently analyzing the feedback it received from the pilot programs and is looking to improve the e-reader, according to a spokesperson.
What do you think about e-readers? Let us know in the comments section below.
HigherEdMorning delivers the latest HigherEd news once a week to the inboxes of over 200,000 HigherEd professionals.
Click here to sign up and start your FREE subscription to HigherEdMorning!


July 14th, 2010 at 10:14 am
These are many of the same the reasons I have not yet purchased a Kindle or similar reader for my own use. The others are price and functionality. Essentially, I’m waiting for the Kindle and the tablet PC technologies to merge into a slim, highly portable, fully functional, multi-function, touch-screen platform at a price around $150 … and they are will come.
I did the same thing with another technology. Instead of walking around with a pocket camera, a pocket PC, an MP3 player, and a cellphone, I waited until the four technologies (PLUS a few more!) were merged into a touch-screen phone at $149.99. I was the last one on my block to own an MP3 player, a pocket PC, or a cell-phone (I did have a pocket camera), but now I only carry around ONE device to do all those jobs … and only one power cord, charger, owner’s manual, etc.!