Higher Ed Morning
Diverse group of college students studying together in a modern library

Research reveals the key factors that determine student success in higher education

ResearchStudent SuccessAcademic PerformancePredictive Analytics

And the Best Predictor of College Success Is...

Groundbreaking research reveals what truly determines student outcomes

A 10-year longitudinal study of 50,000 students across 200 institutions reveals surprising findings about what actually predicts college success—and it's not what most people think.

Dr. Sarah Mitchell

Dr. Sarah Mitchell

Editor-in-Chief

Ph.D. Education Policy, Stanford University

January 18, 2024

12 min read

Study Highlights

This analysis represents the largest longitudinal study of college success predictors ever conducted, tracking 50,000 students across 200 institutions over 10 years.

The Surprising Winner

After analyzing dozens of potential predictors—from high school GPA to standardized test scores, family income to extracurricular activities—researchers at the Educational Testing Institute found that one factor stood out above all others: **student engagement in the first semester**.

This finding challenges conventional wisdom about college admissions and success metrics, suggesting that what students do once they arrive on campus matters more than the credentials that got them there.

Top 5 Predictors of College Success

RankPredictorCorrelation CoefficientImpact on Graduation Rate
1First-semester engagement0.78+34%
2High school GPA0.65+28%
3Faculty interaction frequency0.62+25%
4Study group participation0.58+22%
5SAT/ACT scores0.45+18%

Data from 10-year longitudinal study of 50,000 students

Defining Student Engagement

The study measured first-semester engagement through multiple indicators:

  • Class attendance rates (weighted 25%)
  • Participation in campus activities (weighted 20%)
  • Use of academic support services (weighted 20%)
  • Interaction with faculty outside class (weighted 20%)
  • Peer collaboration and study groups (weighted 15%)

"We were shocked to find that a student's level of engagement in their first 16 weeks of college was a better predictor of graduation than their high school performance or test scores."

Dr. Maria Santos, Lead Researcher at Educational Testing Institute

Implications for Admissions

These findings have significant implications for how colleges approach both admissions and student support. Several institutions are already piloting new approaches based on this research.

Real-World Application

Arizona State University has implemented an "Engagement Index" that tracks first-year students and provides early intervention for those showing low engagement patterns. Their retention rates have improved by 12% since implementation.

What This Means for Students

For incoming college students, this research provides a clear roadmap for success. Rather than worrying about past academic performance, students should focus on maximizing their engagement from day one.

Action Steps for New Students

  1. Attend every class, especially in the first semester
  2. Join at least one campus organization or club
  3. Visit professors during office hours within the first month
  4. Form or join study groups for challenging courses
  5. Use campus resources like tutoring centers and libraries regularly

References

  1. Longitudinal Analysis of College Success Predictors: A 10-Year Study - Educational Testing Institute (2024)
  2. Engagement Index Implementation Results - Arizona State University Office of Student Success (2023)

Editorial Transparency

View our editorial policy

Related Articles